4 Results and Discussion

Field assessments were conducted between September 16 2020 and October 17 2020 by Allan Irvine, R.P.Bio, Mark Fjeld, BiT, Kyle Prince, P,Biol, and Chad Hughes, Ecologist. Mapping was completed by Hillcrest Geographics with a geopackage of project specific layers available here. Results of Planning, Phase 1 and Phase 2 assessments are summarized in Figure 4.1 with additional details provided in sections below.


Figure 4.1: Map of fish passage and habitat confirmation results

4.1 Planning

Review of the PSCIS database indicated that prior to 2020, 480 assessments for fish passage (Phase 1) and 11 habitat confirmations (Phase 2) had been conducted at crossing structures within the Upper Elk River. Within the Flathead River watershed, 126 fish passage assessments and 3 habitat confirmations had been conducted.


Following review of background literature, fisheries information, PSCIS and bcfishpass outputs, 241 modelled and PSCIS crossings were reviewed to select sites for follow up with Phase 1 and 2 assessments. In total, 160 crossings were reviewed in the Upper Elk River watershed and 81 crossings were reviewed in the Flathead River watershed. Not including sites surveyed in the field in 2020, 17 crossings ranked as high priority for future follow up with Phase 1 and/or Phase 2 assessments, 39 crossings ranked as moderate priorities, 90 crossings ranked as low priorities and 23 crossings ranked as “no fix”. Results are presented in Figure 4.1 and included as a zipped Google Earth kml file (Attachment 1).


4.2 Phase 1

During 2020 field surveys, a total of 72 Phase 1 assessments were conducted with 17 crossings considered “passable”, 8 crossings considered “potential” barriers and 43 crossings considered “barriers” according to threshold values based on culvert embedment, outlet drop, slope, diameter (relative to channel size) and length (MoE 2011). Site maps are presented in Attachment 2 with a summary of crossings assessed, a cost benefit analysis and priority ranking for follow up for Phase 1 sites presented in Table 4.1. Detailed data with photos are presented in Appendix - Phase 1 Fish Passage Assessment Data and Photos.


Barrier passability criteria used in this project follows MoE (2011), and reflects an estimation for the passage of a juvenile salmon or small resident rainbow trout (Clarkin et al. 2005 ; Bell 1991; Thompson 2013). As noted in Bourne et al. (2011), with a detailed review of different criteria in Kemp and O’Hanley (2010), passability of barriers can be quantified in many different ways. Fish physiology (i.e. species, length, swim speeds) as well as the temporal variation of physical characteristics (ex. due to flow volumes/velocities a particular culvert is passable 50% of the time to fish with a defined physiological capacity) make defining passability difficult with important implications for watershed connectivity modelling (Bourne et al. 2011; Shaw et al. 2016; Mahlum et al. 2014; Kemp and O’Hanley 2010).


Table 4.1: Upstream habitat estimates and cost benefit analysis for Phase 1 assessments. See Appendix - Phase 1 Fish Passage Assessments for details. IDs are PSCIS idenfifiers with exception of those with * which are interim references.
ID Stream Road Habitat Value (priority) Result (Score) Stream Width (m) Fix Cost Est ( $K) Habitat Upstream (km) Cost Benefit (m / $K) Cost Benefit (m2 / $K)
197520 Tributary to Elk River Elk River FSR Medium (low) Barrier (26) 2.5 OBS 125 2.49 19.9 49.8
197521 Tributary to Elk River Elk River FSR Medium (low) Barrier (21) 2 OBS 125 3.86 30.9 61.8
197522 Tributary to Elk River Elk River FSR Low (low) Barrier (34) 1 SS-CBS
197523 Tributary to Lowe Creek Elk River FSR Low (low) Potential (16) 1.1 SS-CBS 25 1.43 57.2 62.9
197524 Tributary to Elk River Spur Low (low) Barrier (31) 1 SS-CBS 25 1.77 70.8 70.8
197525 Tributary to Elk River Spur Low (low) Barrier (21) 1 RM 1.8
197526 Tributary to Elk River Elk River FSR Low (low) Barrier (31) 3.1 OBS 125 6.6 52.8 163.7
197527 Crossing Creek Elk River FSR Low (low) Barrier (26) 2.5 OBS 125 12.34 98.7 246.8
197528 Tributary to Whiting Creek Lower Elk Valley Rd Low (low) Potential (15) 0.5 SS-CBS 1000 2.32 2.3 1.2
197529 Littlemoor Creek Lower Elk Valley Rd Low (low) Barrier (34) 1 SS-CBS 1000 4.95 5 5
197530 Dalzell Creek Airport Road Passable (14) 5 2.51
197531 Dalzell Creek Driveway Medium (low) Potential (16) 2.5 OBS 5000 2.03 0.4 1
197532 Dalzell Creek Driveway Medium (low) Potential (16) 1.2 SS-CBS 1000 1.76 1.8 2.1
197533 Brule Creek Busato Road High (high) Barrier (39) 7.1 OBS 710 36.95 52 369.5
197534 Weigart Creek Highway 43 High (high) Barrier (34) 4.3 OBS 5000 20.38 4.1 17.5
197535 Brule Creek Private Unknown (0) 36.06
197536 Brule Creek Spur Unknown (0) 34.66
197537 North Littlemoor Creek Highway 43 Medium (mod) Barrier (42) 1.6 SS-CBS 1000 3.77 3.8 6
197538 Littlemoor Creek Highway 43 Medium (mod) Barrier (42) 1.2 SS-CBS 1000 4.37 4.4 5.2
197539 McCool Creek Hadner FSR Passable (3) 12.04
197540 McCool Creek Passable (3) 3.41
197541 Tributary to Elk River Hadner FSR Medium (low) Barrier (36) 2.9 OBS 162 0 0 0
197542 Hartley Creek Dicken Road High (high) Barrier (34) 3.5 OBS 1000 13.07 13.1 45.7
197543 Tributary to Lizard Creek Lazy Lizard Lower Passable (0)
197544 Tributary to Lizard Creek Trail Passable (0)
197545 Tributary to Elk River Mt Mclean Road Passable (14) 2.7 0.86
197546 Tributary to Elk River McGiverin Road Low (low) Barrier (21) 0.5 SS-CBS 100 0.5 5 2.5
197547 Tributary to Elk River Railway Passable (10) 0.5 0.54
197548 Tributary to Elk River Robinson Road Passable (11) 1.2 0.98
197549 Tributary to Elk River Hill Road Passable (11) 1.5
197550 Tributary to Elk River Driveway Low (low) Potential (19) 1.5 SS-CBS
197551 Tributary to Elk River Elk River FSR Passable (0) 1.09
197552 Tributary to Elk River Elk River FSR Low (low) Barrier (21) 2.3 OBS 125 1.33 10.6 24.5
197553 Lowe Creek Elk River FSR High (mod) Potential (19) 2.5 OBS 125 6.45 51.6 129
197554 Tributary to Elk River Elk River FSR Medium (low) Potential (16) 1 SS-CBS 25 1.5 60 60
197555 Tributary to Elk River Elk River FSR High (high) Barrier (42) 3.5 OBS 312 5.99 19.2 67.2
197556 Tributary to Elk River Lower Elk Valley Rd Low (low) Potential (18) 0 SS-CBS 1000 1.13 1.1 0
197557 North Littlemoor Creek Lower Elk Valley Rd Low (low) Barrier (29) 1.5 SS-CBS 1000 4.6 4.6 6.9
197558 Dalzell Creek Lower Elk Valley Rd Medium (low) Barrier (24) 3.8 OBS 5000 2.23 0.4 1.7
197559 Brule Creek Highway 43 Medium (high) Barrier (22) 6.1 OBS 6100 36.82 6 36.8
197560 Tributary to Elk River Line Creek Mine Rd Low (low) Barrier (21) 0.5 SS-CBS 200 2.49 12.4 6.2
197561 Hollow Creek Highway 43 Low (low) Barrier (39) 1.1 SS-CBS 1000 0.25 0.2 0.3
197562 Whiting Creek Highway 43 Low (low) Barrier (23) 0.6 SS-CBS 1000 0.96 1 0.6
197563 Grave Creek Unknown (0) 5.84
197564 Grave Creek Low (low) Barrier (20) 0.1 SS-CBS 25 5.73 229.2 22.9
197565 Tributary to Grave Creek Low (low) Barrier (26) 1.5 SS-CBS 25 5.45 218 327
197566 Tributary to Lizard Creek Lazy Lizard Lower Passable (0)
197567 Tributary to Elk River Cokato Road Low (low) Barrier (23) 0.65 SS-CBS 200 0.69 3.5 2.2
197568 Tributary to Elk River Railway Passable (13) 1.5 0.78
197569 Tributary to Elk River Cokato Road Low (low) Barrier (32) 2.1 OBS 1000 1.28 1.3 2.7
197570 Cokato Creek Cokato Road Low (low) Barrier (26) 4.5 OBS 1000 1.76 1.8 7.9
197571 Tributary to Elk River Cokato Road Low (low) Barrier (21) 4.1 OBS 1000 1.9 1.9 7.8
197572 Tributary to Elk River Railway Low (low) Barrier (24) 2.7 OBS 500 1.93 3.9 10.4
197573 Tributary to Elk River Highline Drive Medium (mod) Barrier (37) 2.3 OBS 1900 0.63 0.3 0.8
197574 Tributary to Elk River Fernie ski hill Low (low) Barrier (32) 1.4 SS-CBS 25 0.29 11.6 16.2
197575 Tributary to Elk River Fernie ski hill Low (low) Barrier (34) 1.5 SS-CBS 25 0.29 11.6 17.4
197576 Tributary to Elk River Fernie ski hill Low (low) Barrier (39) 1.5 SS-CBS 25 0.29 11.6 17.4
197577 Tributary to Elk River Fernie ski hill Low (low) Barrier (26) 1.3 SS-CBS 25 0.23 9.2 12
197578 Tributary to Elk River Fernie Nordic Trail Medium (mod) Barrier (26) 2 OBS 125 2.24 17.9 35.8
197579 Tributary to Elk River Highway 3 Medium (mod) Barrier (24) 3.3 OBS 5000 5.27 1.1 3.5
197580 Tributary to Elk River Dicken Rd Low (low) Barrier (34) 2.2 OBS 1000 1.38 1.4 3
197581 Bean Creek Dicken Rd High (mod) Barrier (36) 2 OBS 1000 0.63 0.6 1.3
197582 Hartley Creek Highway 3 Passable (6) 13.46
197583 Bean Creek Highway 3 Medium (mod) Barrier (29) 3.2 OBS 5000 3.78 0.8 2.4
*4600005 Tributary to Elk R Hwy 3 Low (low) Barrier (39) 2.7 OBS 5000 1.81 0.4 1
*4603294 Tributary to Hartley Creek Hartley Lake Rd Low (low) Barrier (36) 1.8 SS-CBS 25 1.83 73.2 131.8
*4606006 Weigert Creek Weigert FSR Unknown (0) 19.17
*4606515 Tributary to Hartley Creek Hartley Lake Rd Low (low) Barrier (26) 6.7 OBS 168 1.5 8.9 59.8
*4606518 Tributary to Hartley Creek Hartley Lake Rd Passable (0)
*2020101410 Tributary to Hartley Creek Hartley Lake Rd Passable (0)
*2020101610 Stove Creek Trail Passable (0)
*2020101611 Stove Creek Trail Passable (0)


4.3 Phase 2

Habitat confirmation assessments were conducted at 15 sites with a total of approximately 15 km of stream assessed. Six crossings were rated as high priorities for proceeding to design for replacement, Eight crossings were rated as moderate priorities for proceeding to design for replacement, 0 crossings were rated as a low priority and 1 rated as “no fix”. Results are summarized in Figure 4.1 and Tables 4.2 - 4.5 with raw habitat and fish sampling data included in digital format as Attachment 3. Detailed information for each site assessed with Phase 2 assessments is included within site specific reports included as appendices to this document with maps included as Attachment 2.


Table 4.2: Overview of habitat confirmation sites.
PSCIS ID Stream Road UTM (11U) Fish Species Habitat Gain (km) Habitat Value Priority Comments
50152 Tributary to Lizard Creek Mt.Fernie Park Rd 637987 5483407 (WCT) 2.7 High high Newly installed culvert with large outlet drop. Cover as undercut banks, small woody debris, large woody debris and overhanging vegetation. Numerous fry observed throughout the area surveyed and abundant gravels suitable for salmonid spawning. Highest value habitat of 4 Lizard Creek tributary streams surveyed.
50155 Tributary to Lizard Creek Island Lake Lodge Road 635113 5484261 EB, WCT 1.8 Medium moderate Frequent areas of gravels suitable for resident westslope cutthrout trout spawning and pools to 40cm deep associated with small and large woody debris. Fish sampling indicates westslope cutthrout trout fry densities lower upstream than downstream.
50159 Tributary to Lizard Creek Island Lake Lodge Road 633320 5484601 0.3 Medium moderate Abundant gravels suitable for resident and fluvial westslope cutthrout trout spawning. Frequent pools to 40cm deep associated with woody debris. Within old growth cedar forest and not mapped in the freshwater atlas stream layer. Flows potentially diverted as part of a micro-hydro facilty for Island Lake Lodge.
50181 Tributary to Morrissey Creek Lodgepole FSR 648276 5468176 WCT 0.5 Medium high Boulders, small woody debris, large woody debris, undercut banks, overhanging vegetation and gravels suitable for spawning. Electrofished upstream and downstream of the crossing with westslope cutthrout trout fry, juvenile and adult fish captured downstream and only parr captured upstream. Density of parr (fish/area) lower in the steeper habitat located upstream.
50185 Tributary to Morrisey Creek River Rd 645683 5469025 EB, WCT 4.5 High high Good flows, pools to 0.6m deep and pockets of gravel suitable for salmonid spawning throughout. Infrequent large woody debris jams to 0.5m high. Electrofishing indicated generally higher densities of fry, parr and juvenile westslope cutthrout trout downstream when compared to upstream.
50261 Tributary to Michel Creek Flathead FSR 669027 5481115 0.0 Low no fix A 4.4m high chute was located 200m downstream of crossing (UTM: 11U 668858 5481210) and is considered a permanent impassable barrier to upstream migration.
62423 Harriet Lake Creek Grave Creek FSR 660508 5524239 WCT 2.3 Low moderate Crossing dry at time of survey. Incorrectly mapped as Grave Creek. Steep gradients in Harriet Lake Creek approximatlely 1km upstream.
62425 Grave Creek Spur 661486 5524426 WCT 0.2 Medium moderate Deep pools, large woody debris and boulders present. Stream is Grave Creek mainstem that has redirected from historic channel. Higher value habitat in adjacent valley channel. Crossing is 170m downstream of 62426. Westslope cutthrout density study underway within watershed by Lotic Environmental Ltd. 
62426 Grave Creek Spur 661611 5524460 WCT 1.8 Medium moderate Deep pools, large woody debris and boulders present. Habitat quality decreases with distance upstream. Upstream tributary too steep at 250m upstream. Channel is Grave Creek mainstem that has redirected from historic channel. Located 170m usptream of 62425.
62516 Tributary to Lizard Creek Island Lake Lodge Road 636123 5484087 (WCT) 0.5 Medium moderate Undercut banks throughout with small woody debris, large woody debris, deep pools, and overhanging vegetation also present. Abundant gravels suitable for resident westslope cutthrout trout spawning. Fry observed upstream and downstream.
197533 Brule Creek Busato Rd 651626 5528888 RB, WCT, BT 0.1 High high Recommend exploring deactivation as a potential remediatory action. Culvert is located 125m below crossing 197559.
197534 Weigert Creek Highway 43 650144 5532055 11.6 High high Undercut banks, small woody debris, large woody debris, boulders, deep pools, and overhanging vegetation present. Abundant gravels present. Habitat increasingly complex upstream. Watershed is a habitat protection area with motor vehicle restrictions. Elk Valley Park recreation site is located downstream of the crossing. Water too cold to sample. Recommend fish sampling upstream and down.
197542 Hartley Creek Dicken Road 643534 5490723 WCT, BT, EB 7.2 High high Frequent pools formed by small and large woody debris ranging from 0.3 - 0.7m in depth. Pockets of gravels suitable for resident and fluvial salmonids. Downstream crossing on Hwy 3 is passable but requires dredging to keep clear. Historic fish density information available on Ecocat for 3 upstream sites.
197555 Tributary to Elk River Elk River FSR 646735 5554534 BT 6.0 High moderate Good flows, pools to 0.6m deep and pockets of gravel suitable for spawning. Infrequent large woody debris jams to 0.5m high. Sites electrofished upstream and downstream with one bull trout captured downstream within 315m site.
197559 Brule Creek Highway 43 651516 5528829 RB, WCT 23.0 Medium moderate Deep pools, boulders and undercut banks within wetted channel upstream. Adult westslope cutthout trout in outlet pool below hwy. Section of stream (670m) immediately upstream of Highway 43 subsurface during survey. Electrofished upstream only with no fish captured.


Table 4.3: Summary of Phase 2 fish passage reassessments.
PSCIS ID Embedded Outlet Drop (m) Diameter (m) SWR Slope (%) Length (m) Score Result
50152 No 0.90 0.9 2.9 1.5 30 37 Barrier
50155 No 0.22 0.9 2.5 2.6 11 26 Barrier
50159 No 1.60 0.8 3.1 8.0 12 36 Barrier
50181 No 0.95 1.2 2.2 7.0 30 42 Barrier
50185 No 0.00 2.2 2.0 3.4 17 29 Barrier
50261 No 1.80 2.7 1.7 12.0 19 39 Barrier
62423 No 0.18 0.9 1.6 0.5 12 21 Barrier
62425 No 0.47 1.2 3.1 7.5 12 36 Barrier
62426 No 0.25 1.2 2.9 5.0 12 31 Barrier
62516 No 0.49 1.2 2.1 5.0 11 36 Barrier
197533 No 0.70 3.3 2.2 4.0 20 39 Barrier
197534 No 0.15 3.2 1.3 3.4 18 34 Barrier
197542 No 0.40 2.6 1.3 2.0 20 34 Barrier
197555 No 1.48 1.5 2.3 3.5 49 42 Barrier
197559 Yes 0.00 2.5 2.4 2.5 35 22 Barrier


Table 4.4: Cost benefit analysis for Phase 2 assessments.
PSCIS ID Stream Road Result Habitat value Stream Width (m) Fix Cost Est (in $K) Habitat Upstream (m) Cost Benefit (m / $K) Cost Benefit (m2 / $K)
50152 Tributary to Lizard Creek Mt.Fernie Park Rd Barrier High 2.6 OBS 438 2700 6.2 16
50155 Tributary to Lizard Creek Island Lake Lodge Road Barrier Medium 2.2 OBS 125 1800 14.4 31.7
50159 Tributary to Lizard Creek Island Lake Lodge Road Barrier Medium 3 OBS 125 350 2.8 8.4
50181 Tributary to Morrissey Creek Lodgepole FSR Barrier Medium 3 OBS 125 515 4.1 12.4
50185 Tributary to Morrisey Creek River Rd Barrier High 4 OBS 125 4500 36 144
50261 Tributary to Michel Creek Flathead FSR Barrier Low 5.2 OBS 125 0 0 0
62423 Harriet Lake Creek Grave Creek FSR Barrier Low 1.2 SS-CBS 25 2300 92 110.4
62425 Grave Creek Spur Barrier Medium 3.5 OBS 125 170 1.4 4.8
62426 Grave Creek Spur Barrier Medium 3.9 OBS 125 1800 14.4 56.2
62516 Tributary to Lizard Creek Island Lake Lodge Road Barrier Medium 2 OBS 125 540 4.3 8.6
197533 Brule Creek Busato Rd Barrier High 5.5 OBS 710 125 0.2 1
197534 Weigert Creek Highway 43 Barrier High 6.6 OBS 5000 11600 2.3 15.3
197542 Hartley Creek Dicken Road Barrier High 6.1 OBS 1000 7200 7.2 43.9
197555 Tributary to Elk River Elk River FSR Barrier High 5.9 OBS 312 6000 19.2 113.5
197559 Brule Creek Highway 43 Barrier Medium 7.7 OBS 6100 23000 3.8 29


Table 4.5: Summary of Phase 2 habitat confirmation details.
PSCIS ID Length surveyed upstream (m) Channel Width (m) Wetted Width (m) Pool Depth (m) Gradient (%) Total Cover Habitat Value
50152 675 2.6 2 0.3 3.0 moderate high
50155 700 2.2 1.6 0.3 10.5 abundant high
50159 400 3.0 2.6 0.4 11.2 moderate high
50181 515 3.0 2.2 0.3 12.4 moderate medium
50185 740 4.0 2.9 0.4 6.2 moderate high
50261 220 5.2 3.6 0.6 12.0 moderate medium
62423 725 1.2 0.8 0.2 4.4 moderate medium
62425 170 3.5 2.1 0.3 5.0 moderate high
62426 650 3.9 1.6 0.4 11.9 moderate medium
62516 730 2.0 1.3 0.3 7.6 moderate high
197533 125 5.5 3.8 1.5 moderate high
197534 1100 6.6 4.6 0.5 4.5 moderate high
197542 725 6.1 3.8 0.5 3.5 moderate high
197555 675 5.9 3.8 0.4 5.9 abundant high
197559 1600 7.7 2.3 0.6 3.5 moderate high


4.4 Fish Sampling

Fish sampling was conducted at five sites with a total of 154 westslope cutthout trout, 31 eastern brook trout and 1 bull trout captured. Westslope cutthrout trout were captured at three of the sites sampled with fork length data delineated into life stages: fry (≤60mm), parr (>60 to 110mm), juvenile (>110mm to 140mm) and adult (>140mm) by visually assessing the histogram presented in Figure 4.2. Fish sampling results are presented in detail within individual habitat confirmation site memos within the appendices of this document with westslope cutthrout trout density results also presented in Figure 4.3.


Histogram of westslope cutthrout trout captured during electrofishing surveys.

Figure 4.2: Histogram of westslope cutthrout trout captured during electrofishing surveys.


Boxplots of densities (fish/100m2) of westslope cutthrout trout captured by life stage and site for data collected during habitat confirmation assessments.

Figure 4.3: Boxplots of densities (fish/100m2) of westslope cutthrout trout captured by life stage and site for data collected during habitat confirmation assessments.